logo
Bella Notte Pizzeria & Bar
39

Bella Notte Pizzeria & Bar in Pike County

Restaurant
Ad
Places Near me
Overview
FAQ
Review
Direction
230 US-209, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA
pixl
Privilege
Features
  • Restaurant

Privilege

Features
  • Restaurant
Questions and answers
Add review
Ask a Question
Reviews
Add review
Add rating:
07/26 2025
Marissa Ryan
On
1

I ordered a margarita pizza which is normally sauce; slices of cheese and fresh basil and this was not that. The pizza came half cooked and cold

More
10/29 2022
Johanna M
On
5

AMAZING SOUP AND CHICKEN CUTLET SANDWICH LUNCH SPECIAL!! It was so good I decided to leave a review. Hidden gem in the heights!

More
10/29 2022
Jonh Campoverde
On
4

Me gustó mucho

10/29 2022
Wiley Batista
On
5

Great garlic knots love the pizza cool spinning pizza oven

10/29 2022
Jon Rodriguez
On
2

Overpriced slices and just average tasting ordered 1 chicken broccoli slice which cost 6 bucks where I can get two for the same price and fresher. Not Worth it

More
10/29 2022
Justin Grullon
On
5

I live across the street. I love the chicken bacon ranch slice and the garlic knots. Love how they take card and you get a free drink with Two slices.

More
10/29 2022
Josué López
On
4

Great food, great service!

10/29 2022
Ch3rry W!nt3r
On
5

10/29 2022
Armando C
On
3

Went at 1pm and all the pies looked like they were from the night before. Guy taking the order doesnt smile. Pizza was a 2.5 out of 5. Have to make it there after 3pm, when all the old ones are sold out.

More
10/29 2022
Silvia
On
5

Got a calzone, really big and delicious.

10/29 2022
Betsy M
On
5

I order from here alot, today was my first time stopping in. I was craving an eggplant pizza and was told they can’t make eggplant pizza. Only eggplant parmigiana heros but can’t put it on 🍕

More
10/29 2022
Anita Babbitt
On
5

This is such a gem for the neighborhood. Such good Italian food and always spot on with everything. We order from here regularly. Love.

More
10/29 2022
Christopher Volpe
On
5

I ordered a large pesto salad pizza, it was delicious.There was a small problem with my order but called and they were very understanding & as soon as they confirmed the mixup immediately offered to rectify with multiple options.It was my third order from them, each one consistent in quality. The customer service was above and beyond, they use premium ingredients, and the workers care about the impression they leave on you. Highly recommend.

More
10/29 2022
Electronics Guru
On
4

This place might get a 5 if it wasn’t $37 (including tipfor a pepperoni pizza and one small soda. Non English speaking delivery person showed up pretty quick w it though (2 blocks awayand the pizza was great, maybe greasy but we did order pepperoni. .. But good pizza . Very good pizza. Just I felt very very expensive. Also there was somewhat of a mis communication about condiments on the phone and they sent zero napkins. Weird experience overall. Looking forward to trying the rest of this area’s pizza shops. This was our first try!

More
10/29 2022
Olivier Beneytou
On
4

They canceled my order

10/29 2022
Amorita Gharib
On
5

Best vegetarian pizza 😍🍕 friendly staff! Delivery option, fast and pizza is still warm!

More
10/29 2022
Julisa Herrera
On
5

We ordered on seamless. Food was on time and delicious! We had the penne ala vodka w/ chicken, eggplant parm, baked ziti Bolognese and garlic bread. The penne a la vodka was probably the best we’ve ever had. The sauce was creamy and super flavorful. Also, all the pasta was cooked perfectly. The portions were huge too! Looking forward to having it for lunch tomorrow too! This will def be our new go to spot!

More
10/29 2022
Eric Aguilar
On
1

Un pésimo servicio el lugar me queda a 12 minutos caminando y disq eyos no hacen delivery a más de 7 calles

More
10/29 2022
Rick Doerr
On
5

Fantastic dishes, just like home.

10/29 2022
Gabriele Jakubauskaite
On
5

Best garlic knots ever! What a fantastic place, literally won’t order pizza from anyone else, we need to protect local spots like this one!

More
10/29 2022
Nurse Ski-3PO
On
5

The best food hands down in Washington heights.

10/29 2022
Kevin Petersen
On
5

Great pizza. Manager really cares about the quality.

10/29 2022
Gina De La Cruz
On
5

10/29 2022
Dhary Ceballos
On
4

Muy buen servicio y excelente pizza

10/29 2022
Dan Rogenstein
On
5

Easily the best food I’ve ever ordered. I can’t say enough about the loving care that’s put into their food. Chicken soup, carrot soup, meatballs, sausage & peppers, cobb salad have consistently been delicious

More
10/29 2022
ELI OLEAGA
On
5

ExcelenteBonito limpio y buena seguridad.

10/29 2022
Vaughn Armour
On
5

Beautiful restaurant! Nice decor!! Excellent service!! Food was delicious!!!!

10/29 2022
Sergio Sepúlveda Arellano
On
5

10/29 2022
David Lopez
On
5

Both this location and the Riverdale one consistently make great food.I appreciate that they have a ton of pasta options which include vegetables.

More
10/29 2022
George Heimink
On
5

10/29 2022
Maria Trujillo
On
5

Excellent!!❤

10/29 2022
Patrick P
On
5

This is a great addition to the neighborhood, especially considering that they have opened up in the middle of the pandemic.This is not just a pizza shop, like Famiglia or any of the half dozen around here, its a full-on Italian Restaurant. The difference is plain as day when you see their extensive menu, taste the quality of ingredients, and fill yourself on their generous portions. They also do all the pizza, calzone and rolls as well, but much nicer than other places.No, I dont work there. Ive just been working my way through the menu and Ive been fat, happy and full each time.

More
10/29 2022
Taylor Thurmond
On
5

10/29 2022
Armando Caceres
On
5

I’ve had Grandma’s pizza from many places in from Suffolk County to Soho and this is hands down the BEST. Perfect in every way. My new favorite Pizza shop.

More
10/29 2022
Lewis Sara
On
5

Best New York Pie I have tried.

10/29 2022
Moa Shao
On
5

Good value place, would go again in the neighborhood.

10/29 2022
Richard Diaz
On
5

Wow I brought a slice and garlic knots is amazing 👏 😋 😍

10/29 2022
J Mo
On
5

The customer service from the time I stepped in was amazing. I ordered the farfalle wild mushroom, so excited to try this dish. The owner has a restaurant in Riverdale and the food is delicious.

More
10/29 2022
Jessy Gonzalez
On
5

Delivery
Takeout
© 2025 Bella Notte Pizzeria & Bar - 230 US-209, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA.