Cuzzins Pizzeria & Restaurant in Ocean County

The best garlic knots in all of NJ. Tried the polloremo panin and it is so good. Deff a must try

Went out of my way to go to Cusins Pizza in Silverton and got home starving and couldnt wait to eat my chicken parm and penne pasta. THE PASTA WAS SOUR. IT SMELT BAD AND TASTE BAD. I called and talked to the manager and asked me to come with food and would replace my food. WHO WANTS A REPLACEMENT AFTER THEY JUST SERVED YOU SOUR FOOD. I WILL NEVER GO BACK THERE AGAIN. HE WOULD ONLY REFUND MY MONEY IF I DROVE 20 MINUTES IN THE RAIN BACK TO THE RESTAURANT WITH THE FOOD. BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE.

Great pizza & dinners, unexpectedly nice back area for dinners

Ordered lunch and it was incredible! Delivery was good on timing. My new favorite place!!! 😋

Pizza has gone down the past few years. Going to start trying other places since there are so many in the area.

We order delivery from them all the time. Not just to our house but to my work. This afternoon we ordered and noticed that total was a little high for the prices state on the menu on their website. I called back and asked them how much 12 wings were, the person on the phone stated $14.25 I said your website says $9.95. They continued to fight me on the price advertised and then when I asked if they could just honor the price shown, they said "No, thats not what my hard copy says and I cant even get that menu you are talking about on my phone."They should honor prices advertised. I am very disappointed in a place we really truly love.Safe to say, they have lost a loyal customer.

Food was great but who doesnt put sauce on a Hawaiian? And why? Lol

First time trying.. Chicken Caesar salad and pizza was great!

I’ve been coming here for about ten years and they have gone down hill. Third order in a row my food has been messed up. Last time it took over an hour and half for my food which was just ok. Now I get a Buffalo wrap that basically has no sauce in it. Over cooked chicken and let’s not forget the toothpick in the middle of the wrap on each half.

The pizza “taste” is outstanding. However the toppings are minimal. Last time I asked for extra sausage topping and it still didn’t look like a “normal” amount. Something has changed for the bad in the last couple months, things are continually getting worse. The calamari tonight was so hard, had to throw the whole thing out without even eating it. I have spent at least $100 a week there for the last 9-10 months and the consistency has declined. I attached a photo of my sausage, pepper and onion pizza to show the 8 pieces of sausage on my large pie. Very disappointed. 2nd pizza is from another place. That is what it should look like. Lost my business.

Kudos to cuzzins , ordered pizza a mistake was made on their part and they corrected it quickly and were very apologetic, best pizza place in silverton and we have quite a few pizza restaurants! Thank you cuzzins , a stand up pizza place!

Ordered for delivery at 5:05 pm..at 6:18 food had not yet arrived...called and they told me there was one delivery ahead of me and it would be another 30 minutes. That would put it at almost 2 hours since ordering. I asked if I would get a discount if I picked it up. She said yes. I drove to pick it up and they tried to charge me again.They gave $6 credit. She said 2 drivers called out sick...I asked why she didnt call to tell me, she said she had no time.To top it off, the pasta tasted like it was cooked in dirty water and one item was incorrect.

I order all of the time, and have gone in and ate as well and they are all so friendly, the kid that usually answers my calls is so sweet and happy all of the time, just makes you feel good. Food is outstanding!

Maybe they should turn off their slice and DoorDash app and change their hours online if their too lazy to cook when they clearly come across as open ! Then cancel your orders but still answer their phone ! With the bad reviews they have you think they would step up their customer service , and actually serve customers !

Outstanding service and food! Best in Silverton/Toms River, hands down! The server Carmine is super attentive, personable, and went above and beyond for our table. Cant wait to bring the family back again!

Great pizza and gourmet pizza. Dough also sold for your own pizza making nights. Best pizza in Silverton.

I have been ordering from cuzzins for YEARS and lately I have either not been able to get through or treated very nastily by the male that answers the phone. the last time I ordered the price of the pies was way more than we normally pay. I tried to give it one more try this evening and was told to hold then hung up on. I tried again and was told to hold. I ordered from another restaurant across the street and will now give them my business.

The pizza was fantastic I really enjoyed it the cannolis were a little bit soggy shell but the inside was great the garlic knots were mediocre at best other than that I dont really have any complaints and the service was really good so Im happy with them

Wow! I have faithfully ordered from here during Covid and before. I have always enjoyed their food and generously tipped drivers for delivery. Tonight I ordered. Paid way too much for 2 large pies with extras that were not given. Asked for light baked and they were not. Took almost 2 hours. Food was cold. Also ordered a sub, mozzarella sticks and chicken fingers. I paid 90.00 with a 15.00 tip. Each pie was at least 25.00. What happened to this place? So disappointed! Are there new owners?? Delivery guy did not say anything.. No thank you for my generous tip. I will never order from here again. Sorry, but this experience turned me off. I know I dont matter, but I really thought you were better and cared. What a shame because I will share my experience with people who I know also order from here. I have heard negative and I have always said no way. Now I know why! I am so sad to never order my favorite Las Vegas again!

I absolutely love this place, i get a salad from here so much the delivery always comes quick the people working there are nice everything about this place is amazing. i litterly just ordered another salad and it was here within 10 mintues. My mom orders pizza from here aswell a lot and it’s fantastic.

I ordered food to be delivered to my office for a specific time and it did not arrive. When i called the store they told me it was out for delivery and an hour later i was still waiting on food that had not been delivered. I then called again and they told me it was down the road and should be here momentarily that they had to remake it. Well when it got here it was cold and they are only down the road from my office

An hour and 40 mins to have two soups delivered that never showed when Im approximately 5 mins down the road after the hour and 40 min wait time of calling the place for the third time in a row to check status i informed then to cancel the order and the person I spoke with at that point in time just said I shouldnt have been told 30 mins for two soups and I shouldnt have been told that it was on the way pathetic doesnt even describe a pizza place that cant pour two soups from the warmer and get it 5 mins down the road

Ordered personal pizza last nightWas told 25 minsArrived 3p mins later.had to wait 15 mins morePizza was burnt took it because I was hungryThe pie was disgusting

My family and I decided to dine in here on Saturday night to grab something to eat. They had a table for us right away and our waiter was very attentive and helpful. We had the mozzarella caprese and a antipasto to start then pizza and penne vodka. My parents who are both very picky Italian eaters loved everything. Food was fresh and came out quickly. The staff was very welcoming and took great care of us.

Ordered food for delivery earlier today food came within 30 minutes and was hot and delicious. The person who took my order was very helpful. All around great service!!! I will definitely be ordering again

Will not be ordering from here again. Ordered a Caesar salad and chicken soup for pickup on my lunch break. Went in 15/20 minutes after my order was placed and still was not ready even though it was not that busy. But I was understanding and waited. They put food out to which the delivery driver told me it was my order I looked at the ticket and that’s what it said so I picked it up and left. When I got back to work I realized it was my soup but not my salad instead a burger. I know mistakes happen especially in the food business so I politely called back to let them know (as I can’t eat red meat ). The counter girl (who told me she was the manager in for todayinstantly gave me an attitude and blamed me for picking up the order that had my ticket on it and the delivery driver said was mine. I asked for the salad to be delivered since it took my whole lunch break to pick up my order and her response was “you have to wait until there’s a driver available and I want the burger back” in a snarky voice. Which I had no problem doing since I can’t eat it anyway. I’ve worked in a few pizza restaurants and would never speak to any human this way let alone a paying customer. They refused to let me speak to the owner and wouldn’t refund me. My business will now be going to Veraces pizza down the street who’s has better food and nice customer service .

Food is great and staff is friendly. The buff chic wrap and there cheese fries are a must try!!

They have unique pizza called the Las Vegas. We love it and this keeps us coming back. Has a potatoe bacon topping with a white sauce. We usually add mushrooms and spinach.

My family and I order from here almost weekly. Great staff. Easy ordering. Great pizza. Simple like it should be. Love the grandma pie.

I have been buying dinner and lunch for years, at least 3-4 times per week from Cuzzins in Toms River. Suffice it to say a valuable customer. About a month ago we ordered as usual and my wife told the woman taking order to put on a 15% tip on the card, when the order arrived the receipt showed a 30% tip so I called back to have them adjust it (only 3.50 but it was the point). Now they put us on a do not deliver list. I can only image the expected thousands of dollars in future sales will be missed from this managers (Christineridiculous decision. Treat your customers like this and they leave in a hurry across the street to Johnny G’s a place as it turns out is better anyway.

If Your going to sell Italian Food,then do it right!! The quality of the food was horrible. I had Mussels Marinara, It had absolutely no Flavor at all.I will not be ordering from this place anymore.Its Sad when you can get BETTER Italian style food at a Bar..Dont waste your Money here.

Barely anything to go on a Friday afternoon. Got two slices of what was available and half hour later barely made it to the restroom. Not the worst Ive had, but wont be back. Saving grace was the front staff, she was very kind and professional.

Not only does Cuzzins have great pizza, but they have great pasta and sandwiches! I’ve been getting take out and they are very precise and always have everything I ask for! Their delivery is fast too! Very clean and plenty of seating! Plus the service is always a 10, so polite, friendly and fast!

Just tried for the first time, and it was so delicious!! Not only was the lady on the phone accommodating, asked for different cheese on cheese steak, but was also very nice. The driver was polite, and once again did I mention how good the food was..so glad we took the chance on a new place. Will definitely become a regular customer. Highly recommend 😁🍕

I was happy to see they had a gluten free pasta option! My gluten free penne Alfredo was very good. The chicken Francese was great as well. And the fresh baked bread before the meal was delicious!

Love the staff and love the food. One of the best Italian hot dogs in all of ocean county! My mom loves the meatball subs. Pizza is good as well!

Hit or miss. I suppose it depends on who is cooking. Had a great Brooklyn pie one week but the next was totally different and burnt. Same with the grandma. Have gone over 8 times with mixed results. Overcooking seems to be a problem.

Ordered a pie at about 4, I picked it up and shared it with my friend and 2 brothers. The pizza’s appearance was absolutely atrocious and I couldn’t even finish an extremely small slice. Pizza was hardly even cut, had to re-cut it on the table at my house. Cheese wasn’t solidly on the pizza, slipped off the slices and the pizza was undercooked as the dough was moist below the sauce and cheese. Speaking of the cheese, that was the best part (not saying muchbut it was too bad because I couldn’t even finish one small slice. I’m disturbed at their audacity to fold over the pie because it didn’t fit in the box, and there was no disclaimer of this. 3 slices automatically had to be thrown out because of the fold-over. I wish I could add photos of this garbage pizza. Embarrassing pizza place. Not much more to say.

I had stopped in around 3pm on a Wednesday with my daughter for a quick bite to eat and was very pleasantly surprised. Although not busy the food was fresh and delicious and the service was great. Try the baked ziti pizza, its a meal in itself.

I actually can’t forgive myself for ordering from Cuzzins again after the first 400 times they screwed up my order. I figure let time go by any they can’t possibly suck any more than the last time I ordered and every time I looked like an idiot. What shouldBe quick easy delivery takes wel over an hour for cold Food. Stay away

One of the best pizza places in the area. The staff is super friendly and they are open later than many other locations. They were also one of the few Silverton locations that were open during Sandy in 2012.

Worst pizza I have ever had in my 50 years. We threw it out it was that bad. First time we ever had to do that. Sauce was not good and neither was the flavor of the cheese.

I order from Cuzzins weekly, ordered, waited an hour for delivery for it to be the wrong item. Called, they said keep the wrong item and we will send your food out shortly. An hour and 15 minutes later, the food showed up, the fries were cold and soggy which means this food sat for 2 hours. Called and spoke to a girl who was very helpful, asked the owner/manager to give a credit or get on the phone, the guy yelled "She gets nothing, leave her on hold, she can wait." I will NEVER order from this restaurant ever again!!!

Brooklyn Sicilian is amazing. Always have friends over who love their pizza. Good delivery service too.

Ordered and paid for cheese fries and got plain soggy fries. Didnt get the extra dressing I asked for. The bacon on the sandwich wasnt cooked all the way. The pizza was okay. I wont order from here again.

Food was pretty good but not what I wanted . But horrible customer service they seriously messed up all of our food orders and forgot our drink and did not care when I called back up .. then we found out it wasnt even them who ordered it they gave it to Alfredos pizza without telling us. .. then when I called Alfredos they told me sorry five dollars off your next purchase. Like no Im never going to you again the food is NOT what I ordered and I wasted my money.

The food is ok but the people that answer the phone are often rude and they complain about how we pay! They must be millionaires already because they dont want to take our credit card for payment. They say "it takes too much time over the phone". AND the tall blonde girl that works behind the counter as the order taker could not be more rude.Johnny Gs is directly across the street with better food and nice people that will gladly take my credit card information.

seriously, i give many places chances. but this one is horrible !!!first time was great then after that they keep over charging me. from 12.15-12.85 or sometimes 20.19yeaah i keep track.!the guy who answers the phone is very rude !i never order pizzas because by the time they come its cold. and they come 1 hour late or more for pizzasi just order the sandwiches. 30 minsi feel bad for the delivery drivers, i always give them great tips because its not their fault that their owners are a-holesthey kinda complain that i live to far, so why did they leave a menu in my mailbox?or they can just say, sorry we no longer deliver more than 5 minutes.i live literally 8 mins away. only reason i order because i have a little brother that loves this place but he doesnt know that i have to deal with a lazy, rude boss.

If you want cold pizza and wait time over 1hr and 20mins for 2 pies then this place is for you. Pizza from a freezer tastes better then this. I would never get anything from this place again!

My coworker and I ordered pizza, wings and garlic knots for lunch today and love it. We normally order from a neighboring pizza place but since they did not open until 4, we decided to give Cuzzins a try. We will now be ordering from here from now on. Delivery was fast and the driver was very nice.