Fratelli's Wood-Fired Pizzeria in Benton County

The pesto cheesy bread sticks with the balsamic dipping sauce was fantastic and so was the pizza! 10/10 recommend!!

Went for dinner with family and had cheesy bread appetizer followed with cold beer and awesome pizzas.

Not like use to be chicken parmaginina like they put a ton of Parmesan on it. It like what you can get at Walmart. It was little dougy I use some barbecue sauce to get of the bat texture. Next when I call to place order they left me hanging for 4-8mins I placed it online instead.

Middle 7" diameter of my pizza was gooey dough, even though I ordered it to be left in a couple extra minutes to crisp up. I could tell ingredients were fresh and good quality, though. Too much denario ($20+for a medium veggie, no meat, even during these times of GREEDFLATION.

Our favorite pizza place. The best youll find in town, without a doubt. This pizza is for those who have a palate that goes beyond the stuff you come across at chain stores. Much better ingredients, and a lot more flavor!

Good food and great service. Came in for late lunch with the family after a good mountain bike ride.

Wonderful locally owned pizzeria located in downtown Siloam Springs! Friendly staff, great service, and a good selection of toppings. They have vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free options. Make sure to save room for gelato.

Ok I cant stop thinking about the pizza. INCREDIBLE!! I shared the veggie pizza and added pepperoni. Delish. I would not get the gelato if you are expecting silky smooth. It really was more like ice cream, its delicious regardless.Shout-out to Sarah who was our waitress, she was attentive and accommodating to our requests. Definitely try this place.

NICE PEOPLE and the gluten free was so tasty. I got the meatball and would have liked a bit more meatball, but overall, so yummy! The sauce is excellent and you can taste the garlic so vampires, beware! Will be back and I cant wait to try the smores gelato.

Sooo good! I got the cheesy pesto bread for an appetizer and the deluxe salad. Definitely one of the best lunches areound!

Now this place has great options for vegetarians!! Lots of veggie options, delicious pizza, great gelato and nice people :)

Turning into a frequent visitor since I work in the same building. Ive tried several things on the menu and Im never disappointed.

This hidden gem is amazing! I love that the pizza wasn’t all crust like most places. Crust is perfect I loved the flavor! The winners for sure were the Pesto Cheese Bread. I loved the spinach and artichoke pizza I got half chicken Alfredo it was also good but overall my favorite was the spinach and artichoke! Parmesan cheese was $1 for a 3 oz cup but it’s freshly grated! I did try the side salad with their house dressing it was good not my favorite it just tasted a little strong. We will definitely be coming back we had a whole pizza left my husband got a personalized pizza and he also loved it! We’re gonna share our leftovers with family so they can come and try!

Fantastic food and even better service!!! Owner and waitstaff are super!!!!

Best Pizza ever! We got the keto (cauliflowercrust, and its so thin and crispy that it was the best crust out of basically all the crusts weve had, everyone agreed! And the gelato was amazing!

Carry out is great. I love this pizza and so does my family. Expect to pay around $30 for 2 pizzas, soda and gelato. Big kahuna and cheese are the favorites. And chocolate gelato! Nice people.

I haven’t eaten at Fratlli’s in quite sometime, due to the wait time for a pizza. I recently visited and had a pleasant dining experience.The indoor and outdoor dining were full, yet the staff was attentive and prompt. The pizza was flavorful, I enjoyed a glass of wine from the Tontitown vineyard, Niagara, delicious. I also enjoyed a side salad as well that was very good. Great job, Fratelli’s. 👍🏻Phyllis

Very nice touch. Each pizza seems made with care and love. Very friendly staff. Great gem in Siloam Spring. Got to try their cauliflower crush. Glad I did.

Fantastic pizza & great small town feel! The pizza was amazing. Great tasting crust with the wood-fire burn. Wished we had something like this where we live!

We love Fratellis. We want to try a different pizza everytime!

A well balanced flavor, delicious tender interior and crisp exterior crust; highly recommend! I was so excited to find a wood fired pizza and this was the perfect spot for a late afternoon lunch. Great service and a quality soda as well.

Amazing little place! My wife and I brought our 3 small boys in for dinner from out of town. We’re really glad we stopped in. Super friendly staff and great pizza!! The gelato was amazing as well!

So delicious! Always good service and great pizza. I love the crispy crust and fresh toppings. Weve enjoyed their stromboli, cheese sticks and pesto breadsticks. You have to try the gelato too. Definitely a hometown favorite. ❤

Food was great! Didnt take too long and service was good.

The Lady working the register was rude! My husband and I only stopped here cause we were told how good it was. We really just wanted a slice but you have to order a pizza, no big deal, we ordered 2 pizzas and one drink cause I had a drink already. The Lady refused to serve us unless I ordered a drink!!! I didn’t need one or want one!!! Needless to say I guess we’ll never know if it was good!! Rudeness gets you nowhere!!!!

Bread has a weird taste to it. Pizza was very greasy and didnt taste cooked enough. Marina sauce with bread sticks was very watery.

Some of my favorite pizza. It has a thin crust and comes out of the oven really crispy. I would suggest eating at the restaurant or pretty quickly after getting the pie as it can get soggy if left out for too long. We usually order a couple and then eat them at Creek Side Taproom across the street.

Our family really loves Fratellis pizza - it never disappoints! They have so many good options on the menu and the woodfire makes it taste so good. I do love that they now offer the Cauliflower Crust there too, it is much better than I thought it would be!A few of our favorite are the Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Antipasto Pizza, Mile High Salute Pizza, Spinach and Artichoke Pizza, Cheesy Breadsticks and the Pesto Breadsticks. They also serve Stromboli, salads and pasta which are all good too!My favorite is that they offer Gelato - lots of good options and its always a nice little treat after Pizza. They also serve beer and wine and have opened up a back patio too. Great place for a date night or a family dinner!

Aint nothing like a cold beer and pizza after a LOOOOONG week of working.. You know what I mean😏🤨.. That being said; my visit at this establishment was very pleasant 🙂, Beer was ice cold 👍and I dont even have words to describe how good the pizza is💯. My waitress Brooke, very respectful and professional. Ive had a crazy week and to finish my Friday off with such a pleasant experience at this pizza joint was great! So if youre ever in the downtown area of Siloam Springs, AR make a pit stop at Fratellis Wood-Fried Pizzeria! Itll be worth the time.

Ive had the privilege of visiting Fratellis nearly a dozen times over the last two years and every time I leave stuffed and eager to return. The pizzas are amazing and if youre brave (read crazytry the "Nero". The owner and staff put their heart and soul into it and it shows. Top notch stuff!

I cant pass a wood-fired pizza place without trying it. A good wood-fired crust has a great chew, air bubbles and not to thin so it can hold up the toppings. This pizza EXCELLED at all of these things. On top of that fresh ingredients and fun toppings made for a perfect dinner.

First time customer. I was excited to try the food here. I ordered from their website and had an issue with the online ordering system, that caused confusion. They addressed the issue with a quick response and I appreciate that.Fratellis has great cheesy bread and their pizza toppings were fresh and tasty.

Excellent service, delicious pizza, cheese sticks and gelato. Good selection of local beers. Friendly staff. Definitely recommend!!

Covid has taken away much of our opportunities for entertainment, so this month our family purchased pizza every Friday from Siloam- area restaurants. This is based on the opinions of 2 households...3 adults and 6 children. Fratellis failed this challenge miserably... for the first time in my life, I threw pizza- a favorite American staple- away. I tossed an entire pie actually.The pepperoni pizza was so greasy that it took two passes with paper towels to soak up in order to be edible. The sauce and toppings tasted generic or aged. The cheese was thick and stiff and bland. The cheese bread was drenched in garlic sauce. It gave me pizza- at -an -old, run- down- childrens- play- place vibes. Many of us didnt feel so great after. I dont review often, but when I do, I feel its my civic duty. Im not saying the people arent nice. Im saying the ingredients are lacking.

I used to love coming here but the portions have gradually gotten smaller and the prices higher. But the tip of the iceberg was last Saturday. I had been feeling terrible all I wanted was a Stromboli. Willing to pay the price tell me why I promise to go I should have taken a pic I had 4 little pieces of meat and it was. Barely sliced . I have never been so disappointed in the place. Its more so because the quality was not there. Its like they just gave up. It hardly had anything in it, basically I paid almost 12 dollars for some wood fire bread....sighhhh. I hope its a fluke. But Im skeptical and we have a large family so thats a lot of business theyll be losing.

1st and only experience (I live in OKC)Otherwise I would be a regular!I ordered the Nero Pizza. It is the HOTTEST (spicy hotpizza you will likely ever eat! Wow!!! This pizza is legit.If you like it hot, you will love this spot!There are those who say they like it hot,Beware this pizza will expose the fakers!Five beautiful stars for a pizzeria that is brave enough to bring real heat to their eats!

The pizza was so good. They actually import the flour from Italy. You can taste the difference. Try the pesto cheesey bread sticks. You will not be disappointed!

Best pizza place hands down that my family and I have ever ate at. Flavorful pizza and not like any other around. Love the atmosphere and the owners are fantastic! If I could rate them even higher I would!

We drove from Tulsa to be eat here . Third time here . What does this tell you ? Try it , youll love it !

If you LOVE NY Pizza or Italian pizza you will ADORE Fratellis! Perfect crust. We had the Three Little Pigs, and then accidentally ordered the NERO and burned our mouths off! The owners and staff were so sweet and brought us lots to drink and gelato. 😊 We will be back. Thank you.

Absolutely delicious pizza and stromboli! The owner is friendly and casual, bouncing between the kitchen and the restaurant. He always stops by our table to greet us and to make sure everything is tasty. The food is authentic, and the environment is pleasant. My girlfriend and I often go here together. There are options to build your own pizza, and there is also gelato available if you want dessert.

My husband and I have loved Fratelli’s for a long time. The service is wonderful and the food is even better. Try the side salad with house vinaigrette and the Fire-Eater pizza!

We had about 18 -20 people in town for a reunion/memorial for a family member. We decided at the last minute to go out for pizza and went to the restaurant to see if they could accommodate us. The people at this restaurant were so nice! They opened up a private room for us and helped us set up tables so we could talk to each other and visit. We had a great visit because of them and our waitress was great.

This place was fantastic. Was up for a basketball tournament and found this place driving around. The pizza and gelato were phenomenal. Highly recommend this to anyone in the area looking for great food.

The pizza was superb! We had #34 which had Canadian bacon, asparagus, cheese, mushrooms, and olive oil. The crust is real thin and perfect. Lots and lots of topping choices! They also have local wines made just down the road in Tontitown, and a good beer selection. The old building had lots of character with some exposed brick. I would definitely go back!

Found ourselves in Siloam Springs with a little time on our hands, so we fired up ol Google looking for a nice place for dinner. This place had great reviews so we decided to give it a shot and Im glad we did. First let me set the stage... Theres a light snow falling outside, a little Frankie playing on the radio, a local cold one on the table and a bit of pleasant conversation to be had. This is a cozy little place with excellent food, a fantastic local beer selection, wonderful staff, and Don, the owner, is top notch! We joked that we drove up from OKC just to try his place out. Well let me say, it would have been worth the trip if we had. If you are in the area, this place definitely should not be missed!

Just ordered a veggie pizza and bread sticks. The pizza was great! It was a perfect pizza! I wrecked the whole pie as soon as I got it home. The ingredients were fresh and the crust and marinara were the best. I had to upload a picture of an empty box because I ate everything before I got a picture. I ordered online and the pizza and breadsticks was waiting on me when I arrived. They had beer and other menu items for dine in.

Okay, so I usually don’t write reviews, but I had to on this wonderful place. I literally can’t remember the last time I had such an amazing pizza. I got the spinach and artichoke pizza and I couldn’t have been any happier with how amazing it turned out. Also, you’ve gotta try gelato. I personally suggest the Turkish Roast Coffee. The staff is incredibly friendly and they genuinely look like they enjoy their jobs. What a fantastic experience and I will 100% be back many times to come.

Pretty good place. Its a small location and they only have space for so much, but it is worth the wait. You can also order to go. Be sure to ask how long is the wait, maybe you can take a stroll around downtown area while you wait. Or call and order and just drive by to pick up.

Really enjoyed Fratellis! Good selection, waitress made a couple good suggestions. Great homemade thin crust with quality toppings. Wasnt a fan of the Salad. "House" dressing was a balsamic when that was also on the menu, something special would have been nice. Get some gelato before you leave!